What Is an Allowance in a Remodeling Estimate?
A useful tool, and the easiest place for a low bid to hide.
An allowance is a sum of money written into a contract for something you have not chosen yet. Tile, for example, or plumbing fixtures, or countertops. The contractor needs a number in the estimate to give you a total, but you have not picked the tile, and tile ranges from a few dollars a square foot to a great many.
So the contract says something like: tile allowance, this many dollars per square foot, supply only. If you choose tile that costs less, the difference comes back to you. If you choose tile that costs more, you pay the difference.
Used properly this is a sensible tool that lets a project start while selections are still being made. Used carelessly, or deliberately, it is the single easiest way to make a bid look cheaper than a competing one.
Six things to check on any estimate
It states a unit, not just a total
A tile allowance of a lump sum tells you nothing. A tile allowance per square foot, with the square footage stated, tells you exactly what you are being given.
It says supply or supply and install
This is where a lot of confusion starts. An allowance covering only the material, with labor priced separately, behaves very differently from one covering both.
The number is realistic
The test is simple. Take the allowance to a local supplier and see what it actually buys. If the tile allowance buys builder-grade material and you have been shown a photograph of something else entirely, the number is decorative.
It covers the whole category
A plumbing fixture allowance should say whether it includes the shower valve, the trim, the drain and the toilet, or only some of those. Categories with vague edges are where overruns live.
Reconciliation is described
The contract should say what happens if you spend under the allowance. Money coming back to you should be as clearly stated as money going the other way.
There are not too many of them
An estimate that is mostly allowances is not really an estimate. It is a placeholder with a signature line, and the final number could land almost anywhere.
How this makes a cheap bid look cheap
Imagine two contractors quoting the same bathroom. One writes a tile allowance that reflects what you actually said you liked. The other writes an allowance at roughly half that. The second estimate is now several thousand dollars lower, for identical work, and nothing in it is technically untrue.
You choose the tile you always wanted, the difference appears as an overage, and the final cost lands where the first contractor said it would. Except now it arrives as a series of unwelcome adjustments partway through a project rather than as a number you agreed to at the start.
This is why comparing bid totals is close to meaningless without comparing what sits underneath them. Our guide on choosing a contractor in Las Vegas goes through the rest of that comparison.
Allowance, contingency and change order
These three get used interchangeably and they are different things.
An allowance is for a known item with an unknown price, because you have not selected it yet. Tile, fixtures, cabinet hardware, appliances.
A contingency is money set aside for unknown conditions, most often what turns up behind a wall in an older house. On an addition it frequently covers site work, because nobody knows what the ground is like until somebody digs into it.
A change order is a written amendment to the contract when the scope itself changes, whether because you decided you wanted something different or because a condition demanded it. It should be priced, explained and approved in writing before the work happens, and never presented after the fact.
Handling all three of those transparently is most of what you are buying when you hire a general contractor rather than managing trades yourself.
Allowances in remodeling contracts
Are allowances normal?
Completely, and a contract without any is often a contract where selections were all made in advance. What matters is whether they are realistic and clearly described.
What if I spend less than the allowance?
You should get the difference back, and the contract should say so explicitly. If it only describes what happens when you go over, ask why.
Can I avoid allowances entirely?
Largely, by making every selection before the contract is signed. It takes longer at the front end and it gives you the most certain number, which some clients much prefer.
How do I know if an allowance is too low?
Take the number to a supplier and price what it buys against what you actually want. It takes an afternoon and it is the most useful hour you will spend comparing bids.
Do allowances include labor?
Sometimes, and this is the most common misunderstanding. The contract has to say. An allowance covering material only, where an intricate tile pattern also raises the labor, can surprise people twice over.
What do you do?
We set allowances against what you have actually described wanting, state the unit and whether labor is included, and reconcile them either way. It makes our number look higher than a bid that lowballs them, and we would rather explain that up front than halfway through your bathroom.
Want someone to look at it?
Describe what you are seeing, or send a photograph. We will tell you whether it is cosmetic or structural, and we will say so plainly when the answer is that you need a different trade.
Get My Free Written Estimate